Serial jay s inconsistencies

Nov 28, 2014 serial episode 4 inconsistencies this and episode 5 are going to be important. The story jay told police had problems, because it kept changing from telling to telling, koenig says in the first episode of serial. All the inconsistencies with adnan syeds trial witness jay. He s 33, a mortgage broker, more laid back than rabia. Heres what to know before watching the case against adnan. What youre looking at below is a 60 page spreadsheet created to keep track of the jays first and second statements. And, as became very apparent, very early on, and then continued throughout the entirety of serial, there is something very very rotten in the state of maryland. The detectives get a lead that opens the case up for them.

Her brother saad was at rabias office too the first time i went. In both, syed s guilt is questioned, as is wilds s statements. They key characters hae min lee murder victim adnan musud syed former boyfriend of hae min lee. This memo hes talking about is regarding an anonymous call related word. But they were able to bolster the main plot points using cell records from adnans phone. Serial episode 4 inconsistencies this and episode 5 are going to be important. Jays inconsistencies are a point of contention for many people. Jay wilds, the key witness in adnan syeds trial, gave his first inte. Jay s inconsistencies are because he is covering for someone else, this is good for adnans account because it shows that there are other plausible explanations for otherwise damning evidence but it doesnt show jay s guilt because we are using the evidence to build our own stories, rather than have the evidence corroborate our stories.

One of the big things sarah focused on during serials first season was the inconsistencies in jays story. Remember, jay had adnans car that day and his new cell phone. Why adnan syeds conviction all revolves around jay wilds. Why jays testimony is not credible evidence of adnans. Jay totally helped dig the grave and saw adnan throw the body in. Heres your guide to everything you need to know about serial before its final episode.

She also spent a lot of time talking about the inconsistencies in jays story between his two interviews. I wasnt openly willing to cooperate with the police. Inconsistencies a few days after hae s body is found, the detectives get a lead that opens the case up for them. Why jays testimony is not credible evidence of adnans guilt posted on november 26, 2014 by susan simpson in a later post, i plan on expanding further on adnans cell phone records and the related witness testimony, and discussing what we can reconstruct about haes murder from the existing evidence. The prosecutions key witness, jay wilds, refused to talk to reporter sarah koenig for her recordbreaking podcast, serial, which reconstructed the details of the case by interviewing witnesses. Jay from serial gave an interview that might actually help. The call log, though, could maybe support part of jays new timeline. Serial season 01, episode 04 inconsistencies youtube. Wilds did not participate in serial back in 2014 and he doesnt give an interview for the case against adnan syed either. On serial, host sarah koenig honed in on inconsistencies in wilds interviews with investigators and his trial testimony. The motive of him being jealous of adnan s friendship with his girlfriend fits. They bring jay in for questioning and he tells them the story of january th. When jay got the come and get me call he was at jenn s house, wait, james house, and the call came in on jenn s landline, no wait, it was the cell phone. Each season explores a nonfictional story in weekly installments.

This is attributed to jays testimony being everything that the state has on adnan syed, which, is a testimony that is saturated with inconsistencies and falsified information. Jay finally explains the inconsistencies in his testimony. She s adorable looking, but you definitely shouldnt mess with her. Serial is a podcast by the creators of this american life. When i went to sarah koenig, i thought her reporting would uncover the deep inconsistencies in jays story. Weve finally heard from jay wilds, the key witness in the murder of hae min lee. As i noted in a prior post, according to jays testimony at trial. Season one investigated the 1999 murder of hae min lee hangul. Jay from serial contradicts podcasts narrative in first. Syeds case has been publicized in the podcast serial, as well as the hbo true crime documentary the case against adnan syed. A few days after haes body is found, the detectives get a lead that opens the case up for them. Inconsistencies by jialan and sam photo of jay wilds in episode 4 of the serial podcast, sarah koenig gives an indepth look at what jay, adnans drug dealer, claimed happened the day that hae was murdered.

Everything you need to know about serial before the. She s very smart and very tough, and she could crush you. The inconsistencies in jays story doesnt really mean that he is laying or making something up i think he was trying to protect himself and make him less suspicious, maybe he changed his story because investigators were seeing him like one of the major suspicious and he just wanted to make it less probably. Everything you need to know about the adnan syed murder case. Zero in on the most important clues and listen to complete episodes below. There was only jays testimony which seemed, at least in the prosecutions telling, to be backed up by cell phone records. Jay changed his story about the burying of haes body, originally saying that he helped adnan bury her then changing and saying that he only dropped adnan off. She s short, and she s got a beautiful round face framed by hijab. He could have made up the story to put adnan away and stop the friendship. She also spent a lot of time talking about the inconsistencies in jay s story between his two interviews. Dec 31, 2014 there was only jays testimony which seemed, at least in the prosecutions telling, to be backed up by cell phone records. Syed s case has been publicized in the podcast serial, as well as the hbo true crime documentary the case against adnan syed. With jay, it was more so kinda like in my mind i was like, maybe the police are putting him up to this. As jay is turning off jeffs street, adnan calls jay and asks him to get him at best buy.

Serial episode chapter 4 summary march, 2015 soniamontalvo11 leave a comment in episode 4, sarah koenig tends to focus on the inconsistencies in jay wilds story of what happened in the case of hae min lee. He is probably lying because he is trying to explain why adnan, who wasnt a good friend, confided in him about the murder. Jay says hes the criminal of woodlawn hs with a long rap sheet, yet hes only been arrested once. Shes short, and shes got a beautiful round face framed by hijab. Heres what serials jay has to say about adnans case dcist. For months beginning in late 2014, much of america was on firstname basis with the central figures in season 1 of serial, the truecrime podcast hosted by sarah koenig that became a. Serial is a new podcast from the creators of this american life, hosted by sarah koenig. Such inconsistencies, which marked wilds initial interviews with detectives and subsequent testimony, were a crucial part of serial host sarah koenigs dismantling of. It casts huge doubt on whether or not adnan actually did the crime he s still imprisoned for. Jay wilds, the key witness in the state of marylands case against adnan syed, has given an exclusive interview to natasha vargascooper of the intercept.

Jay from serial has spoken out and changed his story again. If youre the kind of person who vacillates back and forth on the guilt of adnan syed in the murder of hae min lee, covered extensively by sarah koenig in the serial podcast, the interview that jay wilds gave to the intercept is probably going to swing the pendulum back the other way, toward the guilt of adnan. Dec 29, 2014 he speaks to the intercept s natasha vargascooper about the events of july 1999, his reaction to the success of serial, and those notorious inconsistencies that kept popping up in his testimony. One of the main problems with the case against adnan which serial plots out is the changing story of jay, and the issue with him as a witness.

I agree, it superficially doesnt sound great that the malls change, best buy comes and goes, the timeline is weird, cathy comes and goesbut at the end of the day, it doesnt really matter. So right off the bat, jays stories are wildly inconsistent both internally. And while the story he told the intercepts natasha. But both jay and jenn say he left her house between 3.

The 12part podcast serial never formally interviewed jay wilds, the star witness who helped convict adnan syed of hae min lees murder. For jays story to have that amount of inconsistencies he had to have been making some parts of his story up. From this american life and wbez chicago its serial. In jays first and second interviews on 22899 and 31599, and in his written itinerary on 31899, jay tells the exact same story. Serial is an investigative journalism podcast hosted by sarah koenig, narrating a nonfiction story over multiple episodes. But the documentary will once again examine the reported inconsistencies. In this episode, sk discusses how the anonymous call led the police to look at adnan, which turned up jenn, then ultimately led to jay. The call log, though, could maybe support part of jay s new timeline. Is there still a case against serials adnan syed after jay. Jay a key witness at the trial, he was a 20yearold graduate of woodlawn high school dating stephanie, a friend of adnan. However, it only exposed the inconsistencies of jay s stories further and cast even more doubt on adnan s guilt. But wilds told the intercept that one of the main reasons for the inconsistencies in his story is that he was worried about how telling about his. When jay got the come and get me call he was at jenns house, wait, james house, and the call came in on jenns landline, no wait, it was the cell phone.

The problem is that jay was, well, a bit of a liar. Jay wilds witness stories and all the inconsistencies. This post is about the fourth episode of the serial podcast. Dec 29, 2014 jay finally explains the inconsistencies in his testimony. Is jay forgetting, fibbing, lying, or something else. The massivelypopular serial podcast ended its 12episode first season earlier this month, but over the christmas weekend, jay wilds, the one and only witness in the states case against adnan sy. Where the shovels used to bury hae were thrown away. Casey laudadio serial multigenre research project essay jay wilds should be credited with the murder of hae min lee. He speaks to the intercepts natasha vargascooper about the events of july 1999, his reaction to the success of serial, and those notorious inconsistencies that. The serial podcast, episode 4 evidenceprof blog typepad.

Jay wilds, the key witness in the murder trial featured on the podcast serial, finally gave his first interview and now the podcast s fans are questioning his account of what happened the day he. Jay from serial gave an interview that might actually help adnan. List of inconsistencies with prosecutors and jays story. Urick stands by the states case against syed, despite inconsistencies in key witness wilds story, which was a focal. But, it s this week s broadcast, covering the purported events of jay s day on january, that proves to be the real kryptonite when it comes to the state s case against syed. In both, syeds guilt is questioned, as is wildss statements.

Jay wilds from the serial podcast speaks, explains. For jay s story to have that amount of inconsistencies he had to have been making some parts of his story up. They find jay at work late one night and bring him down to homicide. For instance, in wilds first interview with the police, he claimed that.

Serial devotees rushed to point out the major inconsistencies between the account jay gives in 2014 and the testimony he provided in 1999. Dec 31, 2014 such inconsistencies, which marked wilds initial interviews with detectives and subsequent testimony, were a crucial part of serial host sarah koenigs dismantling of the states case. Others think the inconsistencies point toward something else chaudry says in the documentary that. Jay s inconsistencies can be seen as an accident or more likely that hes lying. Her brother saad was at rabia s office too the first time i went. In their closing statement, the prosecution contends that this was the 2. Mar 30, 2018 on serial, host sarah koenig honed in on inconsistencies in wilds interviews with investigators and his trial testimony. Jay from serial interview offers new timeline, other details. Dec 30, 2014 when i went to sarah koenig, i thought her reporting would uncover the deep inconsistencies in jays story. Who is jay wilds, and what hes said about adnan syed since. Jay wilds new interview about serial is so completely.

Jay changed his story about the burying of hae s body, originally saying that he helped adnan bury her then changing and saying that he only dropped adnan off. Wait, no, he wasnt at the burial at all, he made adnan do that by himself totally and wasnt even there. At first, he insists he doesnt know anything about the murder. Sarah koenigs serial podcast did a deep dive into the murder of hae min lee and the conviction of adnan syed. Jay wilds, the key witness in the murder trial featured on the podcast serial, finally gave his first interview and now the podcasts fans are questioning his account of what happened the day he. Serial prosecutor calls sarah koenigs presentation of. Shes very smart and very tough, and she could crush you. Serial podcast evaluation essay 1485 words bartleby. But, its this weeks broadcast, covering the purported events of jays day on january, that proves to be the real kryptonite when it comes to the states case against syed. Jay says he s the criminal of woodlawn hs with a long rap sheet, yet he s only been arrested once. And we know inconsistencies in the way jay describes his role in lees disappearance have been a major tension in. Dec 29, 2014 the 12part podcast serial never formally interviewed jay wilds, the star witness who helped convict adnan syed of hae min lees murder.

At the time of adnans trials, maryland rule of evidence 5802. In hbo s the case against adnan syed, this true crime is investigated again. Apr 03, 2017 a few days after hae s body is found, the detectives get a lead that opens the case up for them. The series was cocreated and is coproduced by koenig and julie snyder and developed by this american life.

In hbos the case against adnan syed, this true crime is investigated again. If youve continued to follow the case of serial season one subject adnan syed, then youll know all about jay wilds. Jay wilds, marylands key and only witness at adnan syeds 2000 trial for murdering hae min lee which was chronicled on the hotly debated serial podcast, which launched in october 2014 and completed its 12episode run earlier this month has consented to a single interview with the intercept in an attempt to tell his side of the story. Shes adorable looking, but you definitely shouldnt mess with her. Mar 10, 2019 sarah koenig s serial podcast did a deep dive into the murder of hae min lee and the conviction of adnan syed. Hae min lee, a senior at woodlawn high school in baltimore county, maryland who disappeared january, 1999.